<<
>>

Introduction

Urgency of a theme of research. The organic law of the Russian Federation – the Constitution Russian Федерации1 – defines a state duty (in the name of its authorised bodies) to provide the rights, freedom and safety of citizens to protect property of any patterns of ownership various methods and means, including the inspection which basis is constituted by control checks.

For last years positive dynamics was outlined in work of bodies of the control and supervision, and it affects quality of the government and on formation of a favorable enterprise climate. Meanwhile, superfluous attention of controllers still sensitively for businessmen.

The president of the Russian Federation V.V. Putin has put a number of problems on perfection of principles of administrative activity of surveying bodies, change of criteria of their estimation. In particular, it is necessary to reduce quantity of verifying actions, to enter public otchtnost kontrolno-supervising bodies about results of checks, about spent for their carrying out financial and human ресурсах2.

The analysis of a situation in the field of research of problems of inspection of divisions of protection of legal bodies with special authorised problems service of private security on the basis of scientific sources allows to make the conclusion about an insufficient level of scrutiny of some question. First of all, it

1 Constitution of the Russian Federation (it is accepted by plebicite 12.12.1993) (taking into account the amendments brought by Laws of the Russian Federation about amendments to the Constitution of the Russian Federation from 30.12.2008 № 6-FKZ, from 30.12.2008 № 7-FKZ, from 05.02.2014 № 2-FKZ, from 21.07.2014 № 11-FKZ). Item 2, 8, 17-25, 35, 41, 45, 55//SZ the Russian Federation. 2014. № 31. Item 4398.

2 Message of the President of the Russian Federation V.V. Putin n of the Russian Federation from December, 12th, 2012//Dews. Gas. 13.12.2012. № 287; the Message of the President of the Russian Federation V.V. Putin n of the Russian Federation from December, 4th, 2014//Dews. Gas. 05.12.2014. № 278.

4

Concerns legal fastening of forms of realisation of inspection, perfection of a legal regulation as to activity of under control subjects, and activity of the most inspection commission. Still there is a considerable number of indistinct formulations and positions which complicate understanding and suppose double interpretation of some positions in investigated sphere, that sometimes negatively affects decision-making following the results of inspection by law-enforcement bodies and т.д.1.

1 Decision 18 Arbitration appeal courts of of Chelyabinsk from June, 24th, 2014 on business № А76-26276/2013. Workers of Open Society «Savings Bank of Russia», occupying the post "driver-collector", armed on the norms defined for posts «the senior collector» and "collector", that is the circumstance excluding possibility of reception of the permission to carrying and storage of the fighting weapon by workers of Bank (were broken requirements of the Governmental order of the Russian Federation from April, 22nd, 1997 № 460 in which the concrete list of the posts which are coming under to maintenance by the weapon contains: maintenance with the weapon of "drivers-collectors" in them is not provided).

By results of check the instruction about elimination of the revealed infringement has been taken out. At the same time, the appeal court, being based on business actual facts, has counted lawful court conclusions about illegality of the instruction because the norms approved by the Governmental order of the Russian Federation from April, 22nd, 1997 № 460, do not put maintenance with the fighting weapon of the worker of the Savings Bank in dependence on concrete function executed by it. The appeal court notices, that in check certificates excess of Norms of delivery of the weapon is not fixed, delivery of the weapon to the workers which name of posts is not specified in Norms is made only, and the requirement to hand over the permission in law-enforcement body is not proved by norms of the substantive law; the Decision of Federal Arbitration court of the Moscow district from September, 11th, 2013 on business № А40-147047/12-144-711. About instruction contest about necessity of elimination of infringement of requirements of point 5.1.3 of the Instruction of the Central Bank of the Russian Federation from 27.01.2000 № 87 by entering into the Charter of the changes providing an interdiction for use of the fighting weapon at realisation of protection of places of storage of values of the credit organisations and other legal and physical persons, and also entering of corresponding corrective amendments into orders Rosinkasa from 29.12.2006 № 266 and from 03.09.2012 № 162, since. The applicant has the right to receive in time using in law-enforcement bodies separate types of the weapon, but has no its right to use as the given competence is not fixed by any federal act. The court has come to conclusion about groundlessness of the given out instruction as the right of use of fighting manual small arms at performance of the Central Bank of the Russian Federation is given function of the organisation of cash monetary circulation by article

5

On necessity of perfection both state, and the departmental control law-enforcement bodies the Minister of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation V.A.Kolokoltsev1 specified also. The earlier problems come to light, the less zatratnymi and more effective there are private security actions.

The urgency of a problem of inspection as whole complex of organizational relations proves to be true results of sociological research. During questioning it has been established: 88 % of respondents consider, that in the legislation signs, the purposes and problems of legal bodies with special authorised problems are not accurately fixed; 72 % consider, that the regulatory legal acts regulating questions inspection and realisation of security activity, mismatch requirements of practice, etc.

Regulation of security activity of the private security organisations and check of such activity are settled by the separate is standard-legal block of the legislation. Therefore the author of dissertation has made decision not to investigate the organisation and carrying out of inspections concerning the given legal bodies with special authorised problems.

Inspection subject is the organisation and realisation of security activity of divisions of protection of legal bodies with special authorised problems (further – protection divisions). In the legal literature there is no uniform theoretical interpretation of concepts «security activity» ("protection") and "protection" that leads to ambiguity of their understanding in legislative and pravoprimenitelnoj to activity. Nearby

12 Federal acts from December, 13th, 1996 № 150-FZ «About the weapon» as reception of the weapon without powers on its application in case of need for protection of a monetary cash and other material assets, a life and health of employees Rosinkasa would not allow to carry out the functions assigned to them to the full.//URL: http://kad.arbitr.ru/(reference date: 24.02.2015).

1 From performance of the Minister of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation on enlarged session of board of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia on March, 21st, 2014 URL:https://mvd.ru ›kollegiya_03_201 (reference date: 12.12.2014).

6

Scientists of concept are considered as тождественные1. The part of scientists considers, that the concept "protection" is the general in relation to private concept "protection" 2 and наоборот3, others believe, that it is independent дефиниции4. There is no uniformity in the use of the given concepts and of regulatory legal acts.

Inspection, being the legal form of administrative activity, is carried out during kontrolno-supervising activity behind divisions of protection both state, and not state (commercial) sector. For the present moment in the legal literature division on state and not state (commercial) protection kinds (security activity) is used. At the same time the analysis of the current legislation in the field of security activity allows to classify kinds of security activity also by other criteria.

The legal basis of inspection of divisions of protection represents system of the standard legal acts providing regulation of questions, connected: with the organisation and activity of divisions of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia participating in inspection; with security activity of persons under surveillance of subjects on observance of requirements of the legislation by them, technical norms and rules with a view of safety maintenance; with the organisation and carrying out of inspection of divisions of protection.

Scientific works on an investigated theme is not available, there are only separate publications in which this method (inspection) is considered

1 Stojakin G. N. Concept «protection of the civil rights»//Problems of civil responsibility of protection of the civil rights. Sverdlovsk, 1973. With. 30-35; Alexeys S.S.general theory of law. M, 1981. T. 1. 523 with.; Tarhov V. A. Civil law. Cheboksary, 1997. 426 with.

2 Civil law / under the editorship of JU.K.Tolstoy, A.P.Sergeeva. SPb., 1996. CH. 1. 415 with.; Gavrilov E.P.comment of the Copyright law and the adjacent rights with it. M, 1996. 489 with.; Malikova O. I. Is administrative-legal regulation of protection of property in Russia: avtoref. dis. … kand. jur. Sciences: 12.00.14 / Malikova Olga Ivanovna. – M, 2009. S.11-13.

3 Makarova Z.V.protection in the Russian criminal trial: concept, kinds, limits//Jurisprudence. 2000. № 3. 154 with.

4 Vedjahin n as a legal category//the Right and a policy. 2005. № 5. S.75-92.

7

In certain aspect. At the same time the analysis of regulatory legal acts has revealed a number of the problems requiring a legal regulation and scientific research, including methodological maintenance of supervising procedures. Problems, in particular, concern: insufficiency of legislative settlement of some directions of security activity and nekonkretnost of some the norms regulating such деятельность1; infringement by employees of checking bodies of obligatory requirements at realisation инспектирования2; an exit for limits statutory компетенции3 or "misuse of right" 4; absence of methodical workings out of carrying out of inspection and the analysis of materials of checks.

The above-stated timeliness of a choice of a theme of dissertational research, and also its purpose, a problem and the maintenance speaks. That research of administrative activity of police (including private security) on inspection of divisions of protection

1 For example, a regulation of the basis and an order of application by workers of divisions of the protection, not concerning departmental divisions, physical strength, spetssredstv, the weapon, including fighting.

2 Decision of Arbitration court from September, 23rd, 2013 on business № А68-10442/2012 FAS TSO in which the instruction about elimination of the lacks revealed during planned check in communication by infringement of a notification procedure of the legal person about carrying out of planned check is cancelled. Such infringement concerns to rough and involves invalidity of results of checks, and, accordingly, and the decisions accepted on the basis of this check.//URL: http://kad.arbitr.ru/(reference date: 14.12.2014).

3 In particular, in a number of instructions about elimination of lacks it was specified in necessity to equip territory by chambers of the external supervision, however the given circumstance is not infringement of obligatory requirements and does not come under to execution.

4 Author uses the terminology offered by professor L.M.Kolodkinym. «It is possible to assume, that a considerable part of the accepted administrative acts, the imposed administrative punishments and decisions on dismissal from law-enforcement bodies, infringements of office discipline it is carried out in situations of misuse of right or administrative discretion with infringement of a rationality and conscientiousness at the accepted decision» / Kolodkin L.M.institute "misuse of right" in administrative law: a reality or good intention?//the Bulletin of the St.-Petersburg university of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia. SPb., 2012. № 3 (55). With. 237.

8

Legal bodies with special authorised problems and divisions of departmental protection is an actual problem, 98 % of the interrogated respondents have agreed.

Unfortunately, within the limits of one dissertational research it is impossible to cover all aspects of an is administrative-legal regulation of activity of private security of police on inspection of divisions of protection of legal bodies with special authorised problems.

Degree of a readiness of a theme of research. As a theoretical basis of the dissertation works of leading scientists in the field of the general theory of state and law, the administrative law concerning a problematics of dissertational research have served. These are S.S.Alekseeva, I.L.Bachilo, D.N.Bahraha, K.S.Belsky, V.P.Beljaeva, F.P.Vasileva, I.I.Veremeenko, V.Z.Veselogo, V.V. Volkovoj, E.K.Glushko, A.S.Dugentsa, A.G.Yelagin, J.M.Kozlova, L.M.Kolodkina, A.M.Kononova, A.V.Korneva, V.B.Korobova, A.V.Kurakin, V.I.Lysenko, V.D.Malkova, A.V.Melehina, N.A.Mikhalev, A.F.Nozdracheva, L.L.popova, B.V.Rossinsky, N.G.Salishchevoj, J.N.Starilova, V.D.Sorokin, M.S.Studenikinoj, A.M.Tarasova, JU.A.Tikhomirov, E.V.Tregubovoj, T.J.Habrievoj, A.N.Haritonova, V.M.Shamarova, A.P.Shergina's proceedings, etc.

The general questions of legal maintenance of safety including, connected with activity of divisions of protection, were considered in A.N.Arzamastseva, V.M.Bezdenezhnyh, S.N.Bocharova, A.L.Vostroknutova, I.V.Goncharov, A.G.Yelagin, L.L.popova, A.P.Korenev, A.V.Kurakin, B.M.Lazareva, V.V. Melnikova, V.I.Shestakov, V.V. Tchernikov's works, etc.

Problems of maintenance of property safety police private security were considered by V.A.Abramovym, Of this year Alikeevym, N.E.Bunjakinym, V.I.Vasinym, I.P.Golosnichenko, E.B.Gorin, I.I.Dontsovym, G.E.Dudinym, I.A.Kositsinym, N.I.Lishankovym, O.I.Malikovoj, S.A.Tudosom, V.U.Hatuaevym, etc.

9

Separate aspects of the organisation and activity of law-enforcement bodies under the control over a weapon turn were considered in A.A.Bakayev, A.V.Belokonja, R.G.Golovatogo, A.Z.Glivinsky, O.S.Grigorevoj, I.V.Deljagina, A.A.Dolgopolov, G.I.Kalmykova, A.M.Kononova, V.P.Mak-Maka, S.N.podchernjaeva, M.F.Savelija, V.I.Sadchikova, JU.P.Timashev, E.V.Tregubovoj, V.U.Hatuaeva, V.I.Shalashova, E.D.Shelkovnikovoj's works and other scientists.

Problems of organizational, legal and financial maintenance of protection of objects of the property and public order were shined with private security in A.V.Abramova, L.I.Bochkovoj, F.P.Vasileva, A.I.Vorobeva, V.F.Gaponenko, E.V.Gorin, V.I.Maltsev, O.N.Onishchenko's works, etc.

Not belittling the importance of the saved up theoretical experience, recognising the huge contribution of scientific questions to research of administrative activity of private security of police, it is necessary to notice, that the separate listed questions in this area are only designated, but thus concrete mechanisms of their permission are not offered.

As object of research the legal and public relations developing in the course of activity of divisions of private security of police on inspection of divisions of protection of legal bodies with special authorised problems act.

Object of research are: the administrative law body of rules; is standard-legal and pravoprimenitelnye the certificates, the concerning organisations and practical activities on inspection of divisions of protection; a standard legal basis of forms and methods, functions and inspection principles, and also practical activities of divisions of private security.

Research hypothesis is the assumption that detailed research of administrative activity of private security of police on inspection will allow to develop theoretical and

10

Methodical positions which will promote maintenance of uniform application and understanding of positions of the regulatory legal acts regulating the organisation and carrying out of inspection of divisions of protection of legal bodies with special authorised problems.

The offered ways of perfection of the organisation of inspection process of legal regulation of activity of private security on inspection of divisions of protection should raise essentially their efficiency, lower quantity of infringements from divisions of law-enforcement bodies at inspection. All it in aggregate will essentially raise safety of citizens, property, informativnost reports on the spent checks.

The purposes and problems of dissertational research. A research objective is working out of a complex of the teoretiko-methodological and practical recommendations directed on perfection of administrative activity of private security of police on the organisation and realisation of inspection of divisions of protection.

Object in view achievement assumes the decision of following problems:

- To define concept, functions and inspection principles as legal form of activity of private security of police;

- To establish forms and methods of kontrolno-supervising activity at realisation of inspection of divisions of protection;

- To investigate the is standard-legal base defining the organisation and activity of divisions of private security of police on inspection of divisions of protection;

- To analyse a legal status of the subjects coming under to inspection which are carrying out security activity;

- To specify the conceptual device in sphere of inspection of divisions of protection;

- To define an order, kinds and stages of inspection of divisions of protection;

11

- To develop classification of kinds of inspection and security activity of divisions of protection;

- To develop offers on perfection of legal regulation of activity of private security of police on inspection of divisions of protection.

Methodology and research methods. A methodological basis general scientific methods (have constituted comparison, the analysis and synthesis, an ascension from abstract to concrete and on the contrary, the logic, system and structural approach); special methods (sociological, functional); chastnonauchnye methods (rather-legal, legallistic, methods of development of legal decisions, interpretation of rules of law and imitating modelling).

The theoretical basis of research was constituted by works of the Russian scientists on theory of law, management science, constitutional, administrative, civil, criminal and to other branches of law; the works, concerning problems of administrative activity of private security, security activity of divisions of legal bodies with special authorised problems, safety issues and a weapon turn. Sources from other sciences that has allowed to avoid the highly specialised approach to an investigated problem are used also.

Legal base of research have constituted: the Constitution of the Russian Federation; the administrative, civil legislation and other legislation regulating security activity of divisions of protection; standard legal acts in a field of activity of private security of police of law-enforcement bodies of the Russian Federation, in particular, Federal acts of the Russian Federation from December, 26th, 2008 № 294-FZ «About protection of the rights of legal bodies and individual businessmen at realisation of the state control (supervision) and the municipal control», from February, 7th, 2011 № 3-FZ «About police», the Governmental order of the Russian Federation from April, 16th, 2011 № 274 «About

12

The statement of rules of inspection by police of divisions of protection of legal bodies with special authorised problems and divisions of departmental protection », the Order of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia from December, 1st, 2011 № 1187« About some questions of inspection by law-enforcement bodies of the Russian Federation of divisions of protection of legal bodies with special authorised problems and divisions of departmental protection ».

The substantive provisions which are taken out on protection:

1. Author's definition of concept «inspection of divisions of protection of legal bodies with special authorised problems» as which it is necessary to understand the external administrative activity carrying nadvedomstvennyj character concerning unmastered divisions of protection which purposes are: 1) revealing of the reasons and the conditions promoting a deviation of activity of checked object of divisions of protection from obligatory rules, established in regulatory legal acts; 2) protection of these norms and requirements by acceptance of preventive measures and practical (sometimes in the course of inspection carrying out) elimination of the infringements containing in taken out decisions; 3) generalisation of results of checks for the purpose of definition of the typical infringements made by divisions of protection, and bar of claim by lapse of time of their repeated fulfilment. Inspection also traces process of realisation of own powers by officials of divisions of law-enforcement bodies of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia and performance of the corresponding requirements by them which observance checks specialised body – the commission on inspection.

2. The theoretical design of structure of inspection represents difficult process and includes following stages: 1) a planning stage; 2) a preparatory stage; 3) a stage of planned inspection; 4) a stage of off-schedule (control) inspection (in case of detection of lacks or presence of the circumstances representing threat to life and health of citizens, to ecological well-being); 5) a stage of fastening of the received results of inspection and an information direction; 6) a stage

13

Responsibility of guilty persons as control bodies, and persons under surveillance of subjects (in case of detection of lacks). The check certificate should be an occasion to commencing a suit about administrative violation.

3. An author's substantiation of a subject of inspection by police private security (security activity) as which it is necessary to understand activity of legislatively certain subjects, possessing the right - and capacity on realisation of certain kinds of security activity; actual observance of legislative requirements, standards, norms, rules and technical regulations, obligatory for execution in sphere of security activity; conformity of the internal office documentation of divisions of protection to the legislation and other standard legal acts of the Russian Federation regulating security activity. Inspection is necessary for spending on those objects where the probability of injury of a life and to health of citizens is high (a high class of risk). In other cases – self-inspection.

4. Author's classification of kinds of inspection of divisions of protection of legal bodies with special authorised problems:

1) on the bases of carrying out of inspection: planned, off-schedule, off-schedule control (check of elimination of the infringements revealed during planned check);

2) in a place of carrying out of inspection: exit check, documentary off-schedule (control) check (at elimination of the infringements revealed during inspection in the office documentation of division of protection);

3) in an inspection subject:) complex inspection in the basic directions of security activity; thematic inspection – in separate directions of activity on the basis of the information on occurrence of threat of injury of a life, to health, the rights of citizens wrongful acts or default (inadequate execution) workers of divisions of protection official

14

Duties; specialised – under commissions and instructions of the President of the Russian Federation, the Government of the Russian Federation;

4) on the subjects who are carrying out inspection: internal and external.

5. Author's recommendations about carrying out of inspection of divisions of protection of legal bodies with special authorised problems. The author has defined the purposes and has developed problems, forms, methods, functions, principles and algorithm of this activity, has specified signs of legal bodies with special authorised problems for the purpose of definition of subjects of inspection. Recommendations are developed with a view of maintenance of uniform application of positions of regulatory legal acts and intended for use by officials of law-enforcement bodies at inspection realisation in sphere of security activity.

6. Offers on perfection of is administrative-legal activity of private security on the organisation of inspection of divisions of protection:

6.1. To make changes in item 25 of item 12 of the Federal act of the Russian Federation from February, 7th, 2011 № 3-FZ «About police», having stated it as follows: « To protect on a contractual basis property of citizens and the organisations, and also the objects which are coming under to obligatory protection by police according to the list, approved by the Government of the Russian Federation; to provide operative reaction to messages on operation of the security-fire and disturbing alarm system on connected to panels of the centralised supervision the objects which protection is carried out by means of protection means; to carry out the control (supervision) in an order established by the Government of the Russian Federation at realisation of inspection of divisions of protection of legal bodies with special authorised problems, including divisions of departmental protection if other order is not established by the federal act; to provide in interaction with bodies of federal security service in an order established by the Government Russian

15

Federations, protection of diplomatic representatives, consular establishments, other official representations of the foreign states, representations of the international organisations if such protection is provided by international treaties of the Russian Federation ».

6.2. To make change to the Order of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation from December, 1st, 2011 № 1187 «About some questions of inspection by law-enforcement bodies of the Russian Federation of divisions of protection of legal bodies with special authorised problems and divisions of departmental protection» regarding name change «About some questions of inspection by law-enforcement bodies of divisions of protection of legal bodies with special authorised problems, including divisions of departmental protection» since the concept of the legal person with special authorised problems includes divisions of departmental protection.

6.3. In item 4.3 of the Order of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation from December, 1st, 2011 № 1187 «About some questions of inspection by law-enforcement bodies of the Russian Federation of divisions of protection of legal bodies with special authorised problems and divisions of departmental protection» to bring the paragraph of the following maintenance: «at inspection of divisions of protection of legal bodies with the special authorised problems which are not departmental divisions of protection, the chairman of the commission the employee of division of litsenzionno-allowing work is appointed; at inspection of divisions of departmental protection by chairmen of the commission employees of division of private security are appointed; at realisation of inspection of divisions of the protection which is carrying out security activity on objects of a transport infrastructure, chairmen of the commissions employees of divisions of transport police» are appointed.

The theoretical and practical importance. The theoretical importance of research is defined by its scientific results. Dissertation materials will allow to expand theoretical sights at administrative activity on inspection of divisions of protection, feature of the arising

16

Jural relations under administrative law, system and inspection process. Along with association of available knowledge, their novelty and problem character of the maintenance of the given legal phenomenon theoretical positions offered by the author constitute base for development of new scientific researches in this area.

The practical importance of research is defined by theoretical conclusions and the practical recommendations formulated by the author of dissertation. They can be used in pravotvorcheskoj activity of a legislature, federal enforcement authorities, in legal and methodological perfection of activity of police of the Russian Federation, in educational process for the purpose of increase of legal knowledge and legal culture of citizens and employees of law-enforcement bodies, in research activity.

Scientific novelty of research. The present work is complex research in which actual theoretical and practical problems of administrative activity of private security of police on inspection of divisions of protection are solved.

The most essential results of work testifying to its scientific novelty:

- Intrinsic and substantial signs studied kategorialnogo the device that has allowed the author to formulate concept of inspection of divisions of protection, concept of security activity are investigated;

- Control jural relations under administrative law in the field of security activity which arise are investigated and defined, develop and stop during checks of such activity with the certain characteristic of system of inspection and its elements (the purposes, problems, object, a subject, stages, the form, methods, etc.);

- The theoretical design of structure of inspection of divisions of protection with definition of stages is proved;

- The subject of inspection of divisions of protection is defined;

17

- Classification of kinds of inspection of divisions of protection is developed.

The results received in the course of dissertational research, have formed a basis for formation of conceptual ideas and positions for the purpose of perfection of administrative activity of private security of police on inspection of divisions of protection.

Degree of reliability and approbation of results of research is provided with its methodology and a technique, complex character of research, and also reprezentativnostju an empirical material on which scientific positions are based, offers and dissertation conclusions.

Results of the carried out research have passed discussion on chair of management of activity of services of maintenance of a public order of Academy of management of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia.

Substantive provisions, conclusions and the offers formulated in research, are approved in specific proposals on perfection of legislative base, and also in scientific publications in the form of the manual and 7 articles, from them 4 – in the magazines recommended VAK.

Besides, research materials are offered for use in practical activities GUVO the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, territorial bodies of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia (the certificate of introduction of scientific production in practical activities of employees of the Interdistrict department of private security on East administrative district – branch of federal state state establishment «Management of private security of Central administrative board of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia on to Moscow» from 23.10.2014; the certificate of introduction of scientific production in practical activities of employees of the Mytishchinsky department of private security – branch of federal state state establishment «Management of private security of Central administrative board of the Ministry of Internal Affairs on the Moscow area» from 27.10.2014; the certificate of introduction of scientific and technical production in practical activities of employees of Federal state state establishment

18

«Private security management at Management of the Ministry of Internal Affairs on Omsk area» from 29.07.2014).

Substantive provisions of dissertational research are used by the author also at carrying out of employment:

- At courses of improvement of qualification FKU FACE DOWNWARDS "Protection" of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia at carrying out of employment on discipline «Contract-legal activity in private security divisions», including at carrying out of employment by a method of remote training (the certificate of introduction from 07.08.2014);

- In educational process of chair of the administrative and financial right of the Moscow state machine-building university (MAMI) at carrying out of lecture employment on discipline "Administrative law" on a theme № 20 «the State supervision: concept, kinds, the characteristic», and also at carrying out seminar and a practical training on the specified theme (the certificate of introduction from 05.09.2014).

Empirical base of research the information received during the analysis of materials, prepared in 2012-2014 GUVO has constituted the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia and divisions of private security of police of territorial bodies of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia following the results of inspection of divisions of protection, and also materials of Internet resources.

The empirical base is constituted also by results of the carried out sociological research of opinion of employees of territorial bodies of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia about activity of divisions of police at realisation of kontrolno-supervising powers by them in the given sphere. In dissertational research the data received during interrogation of 251 respondents are analysed, namely: 1) results of questioning of 26 officials fulfilling duties of chairmen of the commission on inspection of various divisions of protection; 2) results of questioning of 89 experts who were repeatedly taking part in inspection checks; 3) results of questioning of 136 listeners of faculty of retraining of the managerial personnel included in a federal personnel reserve of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, and listeners,

19

Included in a personnel reserve of the administrative board of the nomenclature of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia (including supervising the given direction of activity of law-enforcement bodies of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia). Reprezentativnost the given research confirms conformity of sample (participants of interrogation) to general totality characteristics (that is the persons directly participating in inspection or supervising a direction of the given kind of activity).

The analysis of data also is confirmed by the results received and other methods: judiciary practice materials are analysed; certificates of 217 checks are investigated; 115 taken out instructions about elimination of the revealed infringements are studied; the directory materials directed GUVO the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia in territorial divisions, results of check of the State Office of Public Prosecutor of the Russian Federation of execution of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia of the legislation providing protection of the rights of managing subjects in 2013 – 2014.

During dissertational research materials of checks of divisions of protection were studied also. Statistical data GIATS the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia (with 2012 for 2014) on the inspection, concerning a subject of dissertational research were analyzed.

Structure and work volume. The structure of dissertational research is caused by its purpose and problems. The dissertation consists of the introduction, two heads including six paragraphs, the conclusions, the bibliographic list and appendices.

20

<< | >>
A source: Vechernikova Dyne Vasilevna. ADMINISTRATIVE ACTIVITY of PRIVATE SECURITY of POLICE ON INSPECTION of DIVISIONS of PROTECTION of LEGAL BODIES With SPECIAL AUTHORIZED PROBLEMS. The dissertation on scientific degree competition. Moscow ‒ 2015. 2015

Download original source

More on topic Introduction:

  1. in introduction
  2. INTRODUCTION
  3. INTRODUCTION
  4. 10.1. Introduction
  5. INTRODUCTION
  6. approbation and introduction of results.
  7. Introduction
  8. Introduction
  9. INTRODUCTION
  10. INTRODUCTION
  11. Introduction
  12. Introduction
  13. INTRODUCTION
  14. Instead of Introduction …
  15. PRACTICAL INTRODUCTION OF RESULTS OF WORK
  16. 5. Attention strengthening to questions of legal introduction.
  17. Introduction
  18. Introduction